When first shown the
The Uncle Sam Range and the
Savile Lumley and asked to compare the two I couldn't find any similarities between them, one was advertising a cooking stove whilst the other was a propaganda poster that was guilt tripping men into fighting in the great war. But after analysing both images in detail similarities start to arise.
Both images symbolise patriotism and pride but in different ways. The Uncle Sam range poster screams in your face patriotism with the room covered head to toe in loud brash stars and stripes, whereas 'Daddy, what did YOU do in the great war?' shows patriotism but in a more subtle way, with the curtain and chair are covered in nationalistic flowers, the English rose and the Fluer de list, but also the boy is playing with Queens guard soldiers as well.
Both images also convey greatness and nationalism, the 'Daddy' poster is created in the middle of WW1 and is envisaging the future and infers that that Britain win. Not only do we win, the solider is alive, healthy and able to have children, but is also affluent. The first thing i notice about the 'Uncle Sam' poster is Uncle Sam is in the centre of the image and attention. America is physically personified through Uncle Sam and the 'World' has come to dinner which represents America being the great leader of the world but also feeding the world.
There are several other ways in which this poster illustrates Americas greatness, one being the list of food that has rolled off the table. It lists countries and their stereotypical staple diets, this is undermining other countries cultures and showing Americas superiority by saying the other cultures are backward and degenerate. But also the countries on the list are where the majority of immigrants come from thus confirming the superiority. Another feature that shows off Americas superiority and greatness is the font used for 'The Uncle Sam Range' it is a Western style font that has a special place in American culture, it represents civilisation, prosperity and going forth.
Both images targets/potential audiences middle class men. It's easy enough to discover the 'Daddy...' poster is aimed at a man just from the statement and the fact that only men were allowed to fight in the war. With the Uncle Sam image it depicts the male as the centre attention, all macho and with guns on the wall over the fire place.. The notion of the man is the bread winner and that is why the range will be aimed at the man because he brings home the bacon and pays the bills. The reason i say it's aimed at middle class is because i believe both images portray the ideal lifestyle of the middle class, for example the Americans idea of middle class at the time was bold, over the top which is depicted by the large oversized range, over the top deco and the house made/slave. Whereas the British image depicts middle class in a more classier grander style by using classier deco and clothing.